Battleleaderboard

[Alper]

I know, it isnt released yet. But PLEASE dont do the mistake again to make the battlepoints guildcoins based.

Reason:
It has nothing to do with beeing good in battles if you earn many coins. If you WIN you deserve to be in the top, not if you are farming coins. The Festival Leaderboard is a TRUE battleleaderboard. It shows the win lose ratio. It has a ranking.

Leaderboard: Win/Lose ratio based. Adopt the system of the Festivasl Leaderboard but implent a monthly reset (unlike Festival Leaderboard but like the Monster Leaderboard).

THATS a true Battle Leaderboard.

[Alpha X]

Agree. "Farming" doesn't mean "Leading" so if farming coins can take you to lead the battle leaderboard then it is a false rank table and still doesn't mean you're the best in battles. Why? Because a player can just farm coins even by losing again and again, until battle time expires. This way this player gets a lot of coins although losing a battle, while better players end battles quickly and can't earn as many coins as the farmer player.

[Blade Runner]

I know, it isnt released yet. But PLEASE dont do the mistake again to make the battlepoints guildcoins based.

Reason:
It has nothing to do with beeing good in battles if you earn many coins. If you WIN you deserve to be in the top, not if you are farming coins. The Festival Leaderboard is a TRUE battleleaderboard. It shows the win lose ratio. It has a ranking.

Leaderboard: Win/Lose ratio based. Adopt the system of the Festivasl Leaderboard but implent a monthly reset (unlike Festival Leaderboard but like the Monster Leaderboard).

THATS a true Battle Leaderboard.

The OP makes great sense.

Devs please listen to the players on this issue, farming defeats the purpose of battle & competition leadership.

[Mehdi]

Totally agree, farming is absolutely boring and the result is that the Guild Ranking by Points is completely meaningless.

A Win/Loss Based ranking will make the battles much more interesting and fair because those guilds who give everyone a fair fight will be rewarded and not those who negotiate farming-cease-fires with their opponents.
The latter is a behaviour that would be frowned upon in any sport or other ccompetition yet sadly it is commonplace in CA Guild Battles because the Ranking by Battle Points rewards such behaviour.

[Padaxan]

I'll certainly make the point when it gets ready to go.

[Alper]

I'll certainly make the point when it gets ready to go.

Padaxan, you rock! :)